The 4 Best Boutique Hotels with Spa in Shelter Island (2026)

For a relaxing getaway, check out Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, renowned for its luxurious spa treatments and stunning views. Another great option is Topping Rose House, which features a full-service spa dedicated to rejuvenation and wellness, ensuring a pampering experience amidst beautiful surroundings.

If you're looking for opulent accommodations, consider Baron's Cove, offering upscale amenities and breathtaking waterfront views. Alternatively, Madison Beach Hotel, Curio Collection by Hilton provides a sophisticated atmosphere with premium services, perfect for travelers seeking a touch of elegance during their stay.

Absolutely! Baron's Cove is a fantastic choice for families, featuring spacious rooms and activities for kids. Additionally, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa offers family-oriented amenities, including a children's program that ensures everyone has an enjoyable time while unwinding at the beach.

For a romantic escape, Topping Rose House stands out with its charming ambiance and exquisite dining options. Another excellent choice is Baron's Cove, where couples can enjoy sunset views over the water, creating the perfect setting for a memorable getaway.

If you’re a foodie, Topping Rose House is known for its farm-to-table cuisine and vibrant dining experiences. Also noteworthy is Madison Beach Hotel, Curio Collection by Hilton, where guests can savor delicious meals prepared with fresh, local ingredients, making it a must-visit for culinary enthusiasts.

For travelers on a budget, Baron's Cove offers affordable rates without compromising comfort. Additionally, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa frequently runs specials, allowing visitors to enjoy a luxurious experience at a more accessible price point.